Configuration of agricultural biotechnologies in dual agricultural systems: GM cotton adoption by commercial farmers and family farmers in Argentina

Date

2012-06

Authors

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Abstract

Drawing on a socio-technical systems perspective this paper compares the ways in which novel genetically modified (GM) crop artefacts, related devices and techniques, actors, practices, and institutions have been configured across two distinctive cotton production systems in north east Argentina, one based around large scale commercial farming and the other based around small scale family farming. In the former system, linkages between new GM seeds, and new actors, complementary artefacts, agricultural techniques, technical support, and modified supply markets and regulatory rules have resulted in GM-based cotton production systems that perform well. In the latter system, the new GM artefacts were unavailable, whilst conventional seeds disappeared from input markets. Instead, linkages were formed between copied GM seeds, of unreliable identify and poor quality, informal seed multipliers and dealers, largely unmodified production practices, declining technical support, uncontrolled pest problems, and an absence of regulatory oversight, resulting in a poorly performing technology. In effect, working agricultural biotechnologies are different in the two farming systems; they have different characteristics and capabilities and perform in different ways. The paper considers how regulatory and public agricultural research institutions have mediated those configuration processes, and how public policies in these areas could help shape cotton production systems in ways that better support small farmers’ Livelihoods.

Description

Draft – 15 June 2012 - Manuscript for submission to Technology in Society, special issue on “Biotechnology, Controversy, and Policy: Challenges of the Bioeconomy in Latin America”

Keywords

SMALL FARMERS, TRANSGENIC COTTON, SOCIOTECHNICAL CONFIGURATION, SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY, ARGENTINA, GOVERNANCE, GENETICALLY MODIFIED ORGANISMS, BIOTECHNOLOGY, TRANSGENIC PLANTS, SMALL SCALE FARMING, BIOSAFETY, SEED PRODUCTION, RISK, REGULATIONS

Citation

URI

http://hdl.handle.net/10625/50558

DOI

Collections

IDRC Research Results / Résultats de recherches du CRDI
2010-2019 / Années 2010-2019
Biotechnology / Biotechnologie
Research Results (IID) / Résultats de recherches (IDI)